Aging Projects
Extending Health Span:Cognitive Resilience and the Human Brain
Longevity and sometimes the quest for immortality have consumed the human species in mythology, alchemy, and even modern science. The high death toll of nursing home residents from COVID-19 and the ability to keep the human body alive for years beyond the loss-of-self that inevitably accompanies dementia, should focus the mind of alchemists and scientists on the pursuit of healthspan in contrast to lifespan. Scientists look for the answer under the streetlight, because that’s where it is easiest to see. In the last millennium, pathology was readily observable in human tissues; and in the 21st century it has been easy to shine a light on an organism’s genetic information in great detail and even down to a single cell. The strong tendency to define diseases as caused by a perturbation in a single gene attempts to reduce the complexity of human diseases, especially those associated with aging and resulting from a lifetime of highly individual accumulation of insults, to a singular, simple problem. Equally, readily observable pathology, in particular neuropathology can provide a simplistic answer: remove the pathology, cure the disease. The hallmark neuropathology of Alzheimer’s disease (AD), replicated in mice that express mutations in one or two human genes observed in extremely rare, genetic, familial AD, has not provided a target for any effective therapeutics for AD and related dementia. With aging, some individuals with extensive pathology do not develop cognitive deficits nor dementia; whereas, other individuals with modest pathology do develop dementia as they age. Several centenarian projects have attempted to understand the genetic basis of longevity and again come up against the same challenge: the majority of centenarians have equal numbers of disease-associated genes to the general population. Cognitive resilience or neural reserve describes the innate resilience of an individual against the loss of cognitive function and dementia; and we cannot view the brain in isolation, because the body and its microbial passengers contribute to the health of the mind. Therapeutic approaches that increase resilience provide an alternative strategy to addressing diseases of aging and increasing healthspan. One explanation for individuals that lack resilience and succumb to cognitive loss with aging is the “two-hit” hypothesis, in which an earlier life event may deplete neural reserve. The contribution of traumatic brain injury (TBI) to loss of cognitive resilience with aging has been proposed and we have explored a novel mouse model that is highly sensitive to a single closed head impact causing elevated cytokines and other biomarkers of mild TBI. This mouse lacks a key detoxification enzyme, which leads to elevated basal oxidative stress. Although the mouse has a mild cognitive impairment, it has no other overt behavioral issues; however, the basal oxidative stress amplifies the effect of mTBI and also causes an exacerbated response to high fat diet and obesity.
See Publications 6-10.
The Calpain-Cathepsin Hypothesis
The ‘calpain-cathepsin’ hypothesis describes the coordinated and dysregulated proteolytic actions of the cysteine proteases, calpain-1 and cathepsin-B, causing neurodegeneration in multiple disorders including ADRD. Calpain-1, a calcium-regulated cysteine protease, is abnormally activated in the early pathogenesis of neurodegenerative diseases and in neurotrauma, such as ischemic stroke and TBI. The efficacy of small molecules that inhibit calpain-1 has been reported widely in vivo, including in models of TBI, ischemic stroke, and ADRD. Calpain overactivation permeabilizes lysosomes causing the release of cathepsin-B: this second cysteine protease exacerbates lysosomal membrane disruption and causes mitochondrial damage and apoptosis. Cathepsin-B is up-regulated and localized extra-lysosomally in animal models of TBI, in neurotrauma patients, and in postmortem AD brains. Thus, calpain-1 and cathepsin-B are targets for preventing and blocking neurodegeneration. In collaboration with Ottavio Arancio at Columbia University, we developed NYC-438, a potent and irreversible inhibitor of calpain-1 and cathepsin-B. NYC-438 was optimized to increase calpain-1 potency and reducing non-specific cysteine protease inhibition, while retaining potent inhibition of calpain-1 and cathepsin-B. NYC-438 reversed cognitive deficits and restored long-term potentiation in the APP/PS1 FAD-Tg mouse model. Since the brain bioavailability of NYC-438 was low, we hypothesized that the beneficial effects of NYC-438 may be mediated by protection of the BBB and brain endothelial cell (BEC) function. For comparison, we synthesized a selective calpain-1 inhibitor, an analogue of the Abbvie drug candidate alicapistat (ABT-957). During the course of our studies, clinical trials of alicapistat were terminated and surprisingly alicapistat was reported to have relatively low brain bioavailability. We reported for the first time that selective calpain and non-selective calpain/cathepsin-B inhibitors protected the BBB and BECs in mild TBI. We extended the calpain-cathepsin hypothesis to the neurovasculature and are left to wonder if the abandonment of this therapeutic approach in AD was based upon an inadequate knowledge of the mechanism of action of this drug class in the aging brain and a focus on neurons, with less regard for the importance of the cerebrovasculature.
See Publications 6, 11-15.
ABCA1, APOE, and Cholesterol
Alzheimer’s disease and related dementia (ADRD) constitutes a present and growing health crisis in the aging population. Equally, chronic metabolic diseases such as type 2 diabetes (T2D) are increasing, because of the prevalence of obesity and other risk factors. T2D is itself a significant risk factor and comorbidity with ADRD. Specifically, impaired insulin signaling and glucose metabolism, inflammation, dyslipidemia, and impaired cholesterol mobilization are common underlying pathogenic promoters of dementia in T2D and ADRD. ADRD is characterized by hallmark AD pathology (tau and Aβ), with additional neuropathology, and an underlying dependence on neural resilience. The APOE4 allele is the greatest genetic risk factor for AD. Illustrating the important, functional role of APOE, a rare mutation in APOE3 (the Christchurch mutation) was observed remarkably to protect against cognitive deficits in early-onset, familial AD (FAD) in families in which cognitive loss is normally inevitable. ApoE4 is poorly lipidated and lipidation of the apoE protein, required for stability and positive function, is controlled by the ATP-binding cassette transporter ABCA1. Deletion of ABCA1 in FAD mouse models exacerbates pathology and behavioral deficits; and rare human loss-of-function mutations in ABCA1 increase ADRD risk.
APOE and ABCA1 are gene products of the liver-X-receptor (LXR), prompting a strong research effort from Big Pharma to generate LXR agonists that were validated in FAD mouse and primate AD models. However, LXRα activation causes unwanted side effects in the liver, inducing the lipogenic genes SREBP1c, FAS, and SCD1 leading to elevated triglycerides and steatohepatitis in animal. Unfortunately, even highly selective LXRβ agonists that boost APOE and ABCA1 were perceived to have risk, stalling development. We have validated an alternative phenotypic approach to develop nonlipogenic ABCA1 inducers (NLAIs), by screening for compounds that increase ABCA1 in CCF astrocytoma cells with neutral effects on SREBP1c in HepG2 hepatocarcinoma cells. Two hits, shown to have LXRβ agonist activity, were active delivered orally in multiple mouse models, including mice on high-fat diet (HFD), an obesogenic model of T2D, in which LXR agonists exacerbate lipogenesis: treatment boosted ABCA1/APOE and attenuated inflammation without lipogenesis, prompting optimization of one hit using our primary assays and robust orthogonal/secondary assays to give early lead, CL2-57. In a more detailed HFD mouse study, CL2-57 restored insulin signaling and corrected perturbations across the metabolome. Target deconvolution, showed CL2-57 to be a nonlipogenic full agonist at LXRβ and a weak antagonist at other nuclear receptors, notably blocking upregulation of FAS, and SCD1 and lowering triglycerides. We believe these exciting preliminary data validate our phenotypic drug discovery platform for ADRD and T2D; with our focus on hit-to-lead optimization to enhance CNS bioavailability for treatment of ADRD.
See Publications 9, 16-18.
NAD, NAMPT, and the Fountain of Youth
The NIH/NIA Interventions Testing Program reported that mean or maximum lifespan in mice is significantly increased by interventions, including NAD-enhancing drugs. Demonstrated protective actions that combat the aging phenotype include reductions in inflammation, oxidative stress, and metabolic dysfunction, and improving mitochondrial function and autophagy. We hypothesize that the cellular imbalance in NAD+ supply and demand underlies the loss of cognitive resilience that leads to ADRD. Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+) levels and NAD+/NADH ratio decline in the aging brain. Dietary supplementation with NAD+-enhancing drugs (vitamin B3 complex, NMN, NR, NAM, NAD+) has been proposed to enhance lifespan and/or healthspan and reduce diabetes, obesity, and dyslipidemia: all risk factors for cognitive dysfunction and dementia. Miraculous effects were reported with supplementation of NMN. Production of NMN from NAM is catalyzed by the actions of the enzyme nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (NAMPT). NMN is subsequently converted to NAD. Generally, clinical trials on NAD dietary supplements are inconclusive, and ingredients are not standardized. We are designing and developing NAD-enhancing drugs that activate NAMPT, the rate-limiting enzyme in biosynthesis of NAD+, using a unique strategy targeting an allosteric site on NAMPT. These NAMPT positive allosteric modulators (N-PAMs) have the potential to improve cognitive resilience and increase healthspan; and therefore will be of use beyond ADRD, including in age-related metabolic disorders, such as T2D.
The roundworm, C. elegans, is a useful organism for modeling the human nervous system, having a short lifespan. The worms’ transparency allowing visualization of cellular processes. Approximately 85% of the worm proteome has human homologous genes. Genetic manipulation of orthologues in the worm of human genes provides a highly tractable approach to target identification, validation and an invaluable tool in drug discovery. The NAMPT pathway itself, is not present in C. elegans; however, other pathways of NAD synthesis are present providing a parallel approach to NAD regulation using small molecules. This collaboration with the research group of George Sutphin is in its early stages; however, we have much experience with other worms.
See Publications 19-23.
NO Honey I Don't Remember and it Hurts
NO, just a simple nitrogen connected to oxygen. In 1997, Thatcher founded a start-up with pharmacologists at Queen’s University in Canada, initially focused on small molecules that utilized the benefits of NO initially in neuroprotective therapeutics for ischemic stroke. This company succeeded in completing Phase 1A clinical trials in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) for a small molecule “nomethiazole” (NMZ). This project derived from a long-standing interest in understanding the biological chemistry of nitric oxide as a basis for delivering NO in various disease states. The aim of restoring NO/cGMP/CREB signaling in the AD brain, a concept originally conceived by us, using organic nitrates, is now widely accepted.
We have published extensively in NO chemical biology and drug discovery. This is an area of research with high complexity in chemical reactions and poor precision in accurate measurement of the chemical species produced in these reactions. The bias for ignoring chemistry in biomedical research, combined with the lack of reproducible, precision methods for measurement of chemical species in biological samples has significantly hindered progress in realizing the beneficial effects of NO in multiple disease states. We have recently observed that control of NO/cGMP signaling may be crucial to the chronification of pain (hyperalgesia and allodynia) in migraine and also to the related hyperalgesia that is a key component of withdrawal from opioid addiction, which severely limits the effectiveness of rehabilitation from drug addiction.
See Publications 5, 24-62.
More or Less Conventional Approaches to Alzheimer's and Dementia
We are currently targeting an epitope of tau protein that is linked to pathogenesis of AD and other tauopathies, such as frontotemporal lobe dementia. Tau forms neurofibrial tangles that are one of the two hallmark pathologies of AD. However, this approach to tau is not directed at the conventional strategy to clear tau aggregates, or even to induce tau protein degradation. A function of tau in normal physiology is regulation of axonal transport, a process by which “cargo” is transported along axons and neurites: this cargo includes proteins and even mitochondria, lipids, and synaptic vesicles and is essential for neuronal plasticity and function. The tau epitope is the phosphatase activating domain (PAD), which we are targeting in collaboration with Scott Brady at UIC.
In general, our AD research is not focused on conventional AD pathology, since postmortem brains show individuals with severe pathology that do not have cognitive deficits at time of death. The concept of weakened neural reserve or cognitive resilience being necessary for an individual to decline to dementia, independent of pathology, has been proposed by collaborators10. Elevated basal oxidative stress with aging is widely believed to contribute to loss of resilience and there exist multiple stress-response pathways that may not respond normally with aging, including the master regulator Nrf2 “antioxidant response”. Nrf2 activation is a widely explored strategy for chemoprevention of carcinogenesis, wound-healing, and even neuroprotection.
See Publications 50, 63-69.
Is the Greater Alzheimer's Risk for Women Linked to Estrogen Signaling?
In addition to APOE4 risk, women are at greater risk of AD; the exact cause is unknown, but there are extensive studies on the link between menopause, leading to loss of circulating estrogens, and AD. Breast cancer therapy usually involves chemical or surgical menopause and epidemiology has looked at the risk of dementia in breast cancer survivors. Definitively, women who undergo early oophorectomy have a significantly increased risk of dementia in later life. In our collaborations with the late, great Judy Bolton, we explored estrogen replacement therapy (ERT) and selective estrogen receptor (ER) modulators (SERMs) extensively, both from the perspective of the balance of risk versus benefit associated with ERT and the pursuit on an “ideal SERM” that might provide a safer alternative to ERT. The hope is that a safer alternative to ERT would be used by perimenopausal women to dampen the effects of the precipitous drop in estrogen production with menopause. Currently a brain-bioavailable selective human ER partial agonist (ShERPA) is being studied in familial AD transgenic (FAD-Tg) mice that express human apoE isoforms in collaboration with Mary Jo LaDu at UIC. This ShERPA, TTC-352, has already proven safe in Phase 1 clinical trials for metastatic breast cancer.
See Publications 46, 65, 70, 71.